Our Staff


Rev. Timothy Seabaugh

Senior Pastor


Pastor Seabaugh is a native of Wisconsin. He graduated from Concordia Seminary in St. Louis with a Master of Divinity Degree. He served Shepherd of the Hills Lutheran Church, Onalaska, Wisconsin on his vicarage year and served his field work assignment at St. Paul Lutheran Church, Columbia, Illinois. He served as an Assistant Pastor to Redeemer Lutheran Church and School, Pensacola, Florida, for almost five years, until his current call and acceptance to Good Shepherd in the spring of 2005. He served as Associate/Youth Pastor until June 30, 2019 and then moved into the Senior Pastor position when Dr. Rev. Martin Koeller retired. Pastor Seabaugh and his wife Becky have one son Isaiah and one daughter Mallory. 


Jacob Erdman

Director of Parish Music


Jacob, is a native of Minnesota. He received his Parish Music degree from Concordia Mequon in December of 2016. Good Shepherd is his first call. He likes to play instruments for fun including piano, organ, guitar and ukulele. He likes to compose hand bell music. Jacob's parents are Sam and Mary and he has 3 siblings: Andrew and Breanna who are older and Becca who is younger. In Jacob's spare time he likes to play basketball, golf, frisbee, tennis, ping pong and more. He loves watching sports and is a big Minnesota sports fan (especially Minnesota Wild, the NHL team). He also loves to play board games.


Elizabeth Neumeier

Church Administrator


Elizabeth is a native to Appleton WI and has a strong diverse background in Human Resources, accounting specialist and tax preparation. She loves time with her husband (who she met here at Good Shepherd), and 3 children, ranging from 14yrs old to a year and half. She has 2 sisters one of which is her twin, and a brother. She loves watching and playing tennis and most recently pickleball. Also enjoys watching movies and tv shows on streaming networks, crafting, sewing and playing some instruments when she has time such as Clarinet, flute, and guitar.


Church Address and Phone Number:

2220 East College Avenue
Appleton, WI 54915


FAX: 920-882.8978

Church Email Address: